20240714_103245~2
Editorials

Elections Have Consequences: Why Rezoning is Solvang’s Best Path Forward

Opinion: Brian Carrillo

Following this week’s City Council meeting I am reminded again that in California, elections have their consequences. The voters have spoken, time and again, affirming a progressive mandate to address one of the most pressing issues of our time: housing. The housing crisis isn’t just a political talking point; it’s a reality that touches every corner of our state, from urban centers to small towns like Solvang. As much as we might wish for local autonomy, California’s aggressive housing policies make one thing clear—change is coming, whether we’re ready for it or not.

For Solvang, the challenge is stark. How do we meet state mandates while preserving the unique charm that defines our town? How do we balance growth with our commitment to a Danish-inspired aesthetic that draws visitors and residents alike? The answer lies in a new zoning amendment that will give Solvang more control over its destiny. This proposal isn’t just a compliance measure; it’s an opportunity for Solvang to embrace thoughtful, measured growth while maintaining its identity.


The Reality of the Housing Crisis

The housing shortage in California is no secret. The lack of affordable and accessible housing has driven costs to astronomical heights, forcing families to make impossible choices and pushing essential workers farther from the communities they serve. The state has responded with aggressive (and controversial) legislation like SB-9, which overrides local zoning laws to allow increased density in single-family neighborhoods. While well-intentioned, SB-9 leaves towns like ours vulnerable to unregulated development that could fundamentally alter the fabric of our community.

The people of California have made their priorities clear. Housing is a critical issue, and the state is targeting it with every tool at its disposal. For Solvang, resisting these changes isn’t an option. The mandates are here, and failure to comply comes with severe consequences—legal challenges, loss of funding, and a state-imposed housing plan that would strip us of what little control we have left. Instead of fighting the inevitable, we must embrace a solution that works for Solvang.


Rezoning: A Local Solution to a Statewide Problem

The proposed zoning amendment, nearly all but approved this week (I am still confused if was or not), is more than a bureaucratic adjustment; it’s a proactive measure to protect Solvang’s character while meeting state housing goals. By consolidating and updating zoning categories, this amendment allows us to align with the 2045 General Plan and the state’s housing requirements in a way that reflects our values.

The key advantage of rezoning is control. Instead of leaving our future in the hands of individual developers acting under SB-9, rezoning allows us to guide growth strategically. We can designate areas for higher-density housing where it makes sense—near walkable amenities, transit, and existing infrastructure—while preserving the low-density neighborhoods and open spaces that define Solvang’s charm. This amendment ensures that growth happens on our terms, not the state’s.

The new zoning plan also incorporates thoughtful design standards, ensuring that new developments respect Solvang’s unique aesthetic. Under the amendment, we can enforce guidelines that maintain our Danish-inspired architecture and village feel, even as we accommodate new housing. This isn’t about sacrificing Solvang’s identity; it’s about adapting it to meet modern needs while staying true to our roots.


A Progressive Mandate with Local Benefits

Living in a state like California means understanding that progress often comes with challenges. The housing crisis has forced every community to reexamine its role in solving a statewide problem. For Solvang, this rezoning amendment is a chance to lead by example—to show that small towns can meet housing mandates without losing what makes them special.

This isn’t about politics; it’s about pragmatism. The state has set the course, and we have an opportunity to shape how Solvang navigates it. By adopting this zoning amendment, we can demonstrate that we’re serious about addressing housing needs while preserving the heart of our community. It’s a balancing act, but it’s one that we can achieve with careful planning and a commitment to protecting what we love about Solvang.


The Future is in Our Hands

California’s progressive housing policies aren’t going anywhere. Elections have consequences, and the voters have made it clear that housing is a priority. Solvang can’t afford to ignore this reality. But by embracing this zoning amendment, we’re not just complying with state mandates—we’re taking control of our future.

This amendment allows us to grow thoughtfully, to meet the needs of today without compromising the values that have guided us for generations. It’s a chance to ensure that Solvang remains a place where families can live, work, and thrive, all while maintaining the charm and character that make our town unique.

The housing crisis is a problem we all must face. But with this zoning amendment, Solvang can show that even in a small town, progress and preservation can go hand in hand. Let’s take this opportunity to lead, to adapt, and to ensure that Solvang’s best days are still ahead.


 

Brian Carrillo is a seasoned expert in building and construction and is the president of (Joint-tek a consulting firm specializing in seismic expansion joint systems), with over 40 years of experience working on large-scale commercial and public projects across the Western United States.  Brian is a dedicated advocate for responsible development and preserving the unique charm of the Santa Ynez Valley. He actively engages with the community through his roles  with the Santa Ynez Citizens Council (SYVCC) , Santa Barbara Trust for Historic Preservation, the Santa Ynez Valley Western Historic Foundation, and as a board member of the Mission Oaks Homeowners Association. Brian is also expanding his service efforts through involvement with the Solvang Rotary Club.